{ "kind": "historical-backtest-evidence", "note": "Recorded TrainBard metrics from 4 completed joint-candle batches. These are repeated configuration evaluations across related historical samples, not independent experiments, untouched holdouts or live-trading proof. Raw full sweeps remain research archives. Individual buys/sells are executions, not round trips.", "script": "sar-lab.pine", "script_sha256": "86eeb866b1823f15e351842e16c2ab7d72ad88963b2192dda75237003e065a01", "frame": { "initial_value": 10000, "allocation_pct": 99, "startup_bars": 500, "cost_pct": 0.1, "execution": "next-bar market", "direction": "long only" }, "axes": { "sar_start": [ 0.002, 0.004, 0.006, 0.008, 0.01, 0.012, 0.014, 0.016, 0.018, 0.02, 0.022, 0.024, 0.026, 0.028, 0.03, 0.032, 0.034, 0.036, 0.038, 0.04, 0.042, 0.044, 0.046, 0.048, 0.05 ], "sar_step": [ 0.002, 0.004, 0.006, 0.008, 0.01, 0.012, 0.014, 0.016, 0.018, 0.02, 0.022, 0.024, 0.026, 0.028, 0.03, 0.032, 0.034, 0.036, 0.038, 0.04, 0.042, 0.044, 0.046, 0.048, 0.05 ], "sar_max": [ 0.1, 0.15, 0.2, 0.25, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5 ], "confirm_bars": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ], "candleSize": [ "2h", "4h" ] }, "requested": 175000, "valid": 175000, "traded": 175000, "invalid": 0, "valid_zero_trade": 0, "errors": 0, "duplicates": 0, "excluded_diagnostics": { "D001": 5, "D002": 3 }, "frames": [ { "batch": "B001", "symbol": "BTCUSDT", "window": "early", "start_date": "2021-01-01", "end_date": "2023-12-31", "candleSize": "2h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 0, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -75.23920440673828, "finalValue": 2476.079833984375, "totalTrades": 899, "winRate": 31.403118133544922, "maxDrawdownPct": 80.11820983886719, "totalFees": 3487.8291015625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.05871574580669403 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -80.44132995605469, "finalValue": 1955.8673095703125, "totalTrades": 953, "winRate": 30.882352828979492, "maxDrawdownPct": 84.916259765625, "totalFees": 3529.671875, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04637984558939934 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -80.02999114990234, "finalValue": 1997.001220703125, "totalTrades": 963, "winRate": 30.977130889892578, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.74506378173828, "totalFees": 3710.26708984375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04735526069998741 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -80.12854766845703, "finalValue": 1987.1455078125, "totalTrades": 965, "winRate": 30.91286277770996, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.82528686523438, "totalFees": 3707.484619140625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.047121550887823105 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -80.12854766845703, "finalValue": 1987.1455078125, "totalTrades": 965, "winRate": 30.91286277770996, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.82528686523438, "totalFees": 3707.484619140625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.047121550887823105 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -80.12854766845703, "finalValue": 1987.1455078125, "totalTrades": 965, "winRate": 30.91286277770996, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.82528686523438, "totalFees": 3707.484619140625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.047121550887823105 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -80.12854766845703, "finalValue": 1987.1455078125, "totalTrades": 965, "winRate": 30.91286277770996, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.82528686523438, "totalFees": 3707.484619140625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.047121550887823105 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -80.02999114990234, "finalValue": 1997.001220703125, "totalTrades": 963, "winRate": 30.977130889892578, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.74506378173828, "totalFees": 3710.26708984375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04735526069998741 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -46.982765197753906, "finalValue": 5301.7236328125, "totalTrades": 248, "winRate": 29.032258987426758, "maxDrawdownPct": 70.63029479980469, "totalFees": 1507.9095458984375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.12572075426578522 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": -10.947732925415039, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 43.3887939453125, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1192, "same_return": 965, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 965, "higher_return": 464, "same_count_different_return": 227, "more_executions": 1913, "lower_return": 1696, "fewer_executions": 20 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 2995, "same_return": 2755, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 2755, "higher_return": 170, "same_count_different_return": 240, "lower_return": 200, "more_executions": 130 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 28, "higher_return": 2096, "same_count_different_return": 28, "fewer_executions": 4347, "lower_return": 2279 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B001-btcusdt-early-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "453d4ccafa8cbfdf0a76f4327a968b0eab95c5b9711f02f8235c2785d3d650a8" }, { "batch": "B001", "symbol": "BTCUSDT", "window": "early", "start_date": "2021-01-01", "end_date": "2023-12-31", "candleSize": "4h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 315, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -15.473616600036621, "finalValue": 8452.638671875, "totalTrades": 426, "winRate": 33.33333206176758, "maxDrawdownPct": 53.68071365356445, "totalFees": 3274.6806640625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.20041346549987793 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -24.607948303222656, "finalValue": 7539.205078125, "totalTrades": 450, "winRate": 33.33333206176758, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.89216232299805, "totalFees": 3382.318603515625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.17875580489635468 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -31.78856658935547, "finalValue": 6821.14306640625, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 61.01775360107422, "totalFees": 3197.2666015625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.16173045337200165 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -27.331981658935547, "finalValue": 7266.8017578125, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 58.57819747924805, "totalFees": 3286.78125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.17229709029197693 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -27.331981658935547, "finalValue": 7266.8017578125, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 58.57819747924805, "totalFees": 3286.78125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.17229709029197693 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -27.331981658935547, "finalValue": 7266.8017578125, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 58.57819747924805, "totalFees": 3286.78125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.17229709029197693 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -27.331981658935547, "finalValue": 7266.8017578125, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 58.57819747924805, "totalFees": 3286.78125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.17229709029197693 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -31.78856658935547, "finalValue": 6821.14306640625, "totalTrades": 462, "winRate": 33.7662353515625, "maxDrawdownPct": 61.01775360107422, "totalFees": 3197.2666015625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.16173045337200165 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": 78.39432525634766, "finalValue": 17839.43359375, "totalTrades": 106, "winRate": 39.622642517089844, "maxDrawdownPct": 33.709571838378906, "totalFees": 1336.5213623046875, "finalCoinAmount": 0.42297592759132385 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": -19.03457260131836, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 44.05158615112305, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1517, "same_return": 733, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 733, "higher_return": 1126, "same_count_different_return": 784, "lower_return": 1266, "fewer_executions": 75, "more_executions": 1533 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3080, "same_return": 2500, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 2500, "higher_return": 610, "same_count_different_return": 580, "lower_return": 15, "fewer_executions": 42, "more_executions": 3 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 120, "lower_return": 4264, "same_count_different_return": 120, "fewer_executions": 4255, "higher_return": 111 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B001-btcusdt-early-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "453d4ccafa8cbfdf0a76f4327a968b0eab95c5b9711f02f8235c2785d3d650a8" }, { "batch": "B002", "symbol": "ETHUSDT", "window": "early", "start_date": "2021-01-01", "end_date": "2023-12-31", "candleSize": "2h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 1557, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -63.98033905029297, "finalValue": 3601.966064453125, "totalTrades": 896, "winRate": 35.9375, "maxDrawdownPct": 82.28398132324219, "totalFees": 4422.91796875, "finalCoinAmount": 1.5730483531951904 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -66.13887786865234, "finalValue": 3386.1123046875, "totalTrades": 950, "winRate": 36.6315803527832, "maxDrawdownPct": 78.31596374511719, "totalFees": 4603.25927734375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.4787808656692505 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -67.5135269165039, "finalValue": 3248.647216796875, "totalTrades": 960, "winRate": 36.45833206176758, "maxDrawdownPct": 78.33817291259766, "totalFees": 4706.08935546875, "finalCoinAmount": 1.4187471866607666 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -63.749229431152344, "finalValue": 3625.0771484375, "totalTrades": 962, "winRate": 36.59043502807617, "maxDrawdownPct": 77.17513275146484, "totalFees": 4964.166015625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.5831414461135864 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -63.749229431152344, "finalValue": 3625.0771484375, "totalTrades": 962, "winRate": 36.59043502807617, "maxDrawdownPct": 77.17513275146484, "totalFees": 4964.166015625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.5831414461135864 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -63.749229431152344, "finalValue": 3625.0771484375, "totalTrades": 962, "winRate": 36.59043502807617, "maxDrawdownPct": 77.17513275146484, "totalFees": 4964.166015625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.5831414461135864 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -63.749229431152344, "finalValue": 3625.0771484375, "totalTrades": 962, "winRate": 36.59043502807617, "maxDrawdownPct": 77.17513275146484, "totalFees": 4964.166015625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.5831414461135864 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -67.5135269165039, "finalValue": 3248.647216796875, "totalTrades": 960, "winRate": 36.45833206176758, "maxDrawdownPct": 78.33817291259766, "totalFees": 4706.08935546875, "finalCoinAmount": 1.4187471866607666 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -69.68944549560547, "finalValue": 3031.0556640625, "totalTrades": 259, "winRate": 31.00775146484375, "maxDrawdownPct": 85.2629165649414, "totalFees": 1393.5843505859375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.3237206935882568 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": 28.105424880981445, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 206.00845336914062, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1105, "same_return": 875, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 875, "higher_return": 631, "same_count_different_return": 230, "lower_return": 1619, "fewer_executions": 5, "more_executions": 2015 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3125, "same_return": 2610, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 2610, "higher_return": 515, "same_count_different_return": 515 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 177, "lower_return": 180, "same_count_different_return": 177, "higher_return": 4195, "fewer_executions": 4198 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B002-ethusdt-early-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "739ccce58a417d2960f6d29a26150ab7331381fd67f5bcb8ac98f0c97211dbc6" }, { "batch": "B002", "symbol": "ETHUSDT", "window": "early", "start_date": "2021-01-01", "end_date": "2023-12-31", "candleSize": "4h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 937, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -8.490518569946289, "finalValue": 9150.9482421875, "totalTrades": 428, "winRate": 40.654205322265625, "maxDrawdownPct": 73.29428100585938, "totalFees": 4032.272216796875, "finalCoinAmount": 4.006509780883789 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -54.838802337646484, "finalValue": 4516.11962890625, "totalTrades": 470, "winRate": 39.574466705322266, "maxDrawdownPct": 81.63969421386719, "totalFees": 3118.124755859375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9772679805755615 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -59.7963752746582, "finalValue": 4020.362548828125, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2963.08056640625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7602133750915527 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -60.386962890625, "finalValue": 3961.3037109375, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2922.5849609375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7343560457229614 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -60.386962890625, "finalValue": 3961.3037109375, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2922.5849609375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7343560457229614 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -60.386962890625, "finalValue": 3961.3037109375, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2922.5849609375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7343560457229614 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -60.386962890625, "finalValue": 3961.3037109375, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2922.5849609375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7343560457229614 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -59.7963752746582, "finalValue": 4020.362548828125, "totalTrades": 476, "winRate": 39.49580001831055, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.20873260498047, "totalFees": 2963.08056640625, "finalCoinAmount": 1.7602133750915527 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": 103.17457580566406, "finalValue": 20317.45703125, "totalTrades": 119, "winRate": 42.37288284301758, "maxDrawdownPct": 43.69007873535156, "totalFees": 2268.094970703125, "finalCoinAmount": 8.895482063293457 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": 42.85165023803711, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 206.65396118164062, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1444, "same_return": 840, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 840, "lower_return": 923, "same_count_different_return": 604, "more_executions": 1639, "higher_return": 1362, "fewer_executions": 42 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3074, "same_return": 2844, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 2844, "higher_return": 197, "same_count_different_return": 230, "fewer_executions": 12, "more_executions": 39, "lower_return": 84 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 212, "lower_return": 3295, "same_count_different_return": 212, "fewer_executions": 4163, "higher_return": 1080 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B002-ethusdt-early-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "739ccce58a417d2960f6d29a26150ab7331381fd67f5bcb8ac98f0c97211dbc6" }, { "batch": "B003", "symbol": "BTCUSDT", "window": "later", "start_date": "2024-01-01", "end_date": "2025-12-31", "candleSize": "2h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 1477, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -59.85662078857422, "finalValue": 4014.337890625, "totalTrades": 644, "winRate": 36.024845123291016, "maxDrawdownPct": 65.78820037841797, "totalFees": 5283.7431640625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04528333991765976 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -62.60474395751953, "finalValue": 3739.525634765625, "totalTrades": 678, "winRate": 35.98820114135742, "maxDrawdownPct": 69.35673522949219, "totalFees": 5675.0322265625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04218335077166557 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -63.293819427490234, "finalValue": 3670.617919921875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.80841827392578, "totalFees": 5577.9111328125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.041406042873859406 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -62.76708221435547, "finalValue": 3723.291748046875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.3608169555664, "totalFees": 5637.26953125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04200022667646408 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -62.76708221435547, "finalValue": 3723.291748046875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.3608169555664, "totalFees": 5637.26953125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04200022667646408 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -62.76708221435547, "finalValue": 3723.291748046875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.3608169555664, "totalFees": 5637.26953125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04200022667646408 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -62.76708221435547, "finalValue": 3723.291748046875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.3608169555664, "totalFees": 5637.26953125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04200022667646408 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -63.293819427490234, "finalValue": 3670.617919921875, "totalTrades": 686, "winRate": 35.568511962890625, "maxDrawdownPct": 68.80841827392578, "totalFees": 5577.9111328125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.041406042873859406 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": 50.699710845947266, "finalValue": 15069.970703125, "totalTrades": 161, "winRate": 41.25, "maxDrawdownPct": 29.937362670898438, "totalFees": 2487.6337890625, "finalCoinAmount": 0.16999532282352448 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": 82.5521240234375, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 108.03079986572266, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1277, "same_return": 690, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 690, "higher_return": 1113, "same_count_different_return": 587, "lower_return": 1322, "fewer_executions": 69, "more_executions": 1779 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3125, "same_return": 3125, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 3125 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 98, "lower_return": 1403, "same_count_different_return": 98, "fewer_executions": 4277, "higher_return": 2972 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B003-btcusdt-later-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "5a472fba010e0de163cd4cabc017ae95d48926ca4f8a4019acec768b36446545" }, { "batch": "B003", "symbol": "BTCUSDT", "window": "later", "start_date": "2024-01-01", "end_date": "2025-12-31", "candleSize": "4h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 5296, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -26.69400405883789, "finalValue": 7330.599609375, "totalTrades": 288, "winRate": 34.72222137451172, "maxDrawdownPct": 47.82367706298828, "totalFees": 2774.00439453125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08287560939788818 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -27.41836929321289, "finalValue": 7258.1630859375, "totalTrades": 318, "winRate": 33.33333206176758, "maxDrawdownPct": 52.88945388793945, "totalFees": 3185.9052734375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.0820566862821579 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -21.344327926635742, "finalValue": 7865.5673828125, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.1760368347168, "totalFees": 3331.003662109375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08892364799976349 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -21.798145294189453, "finalValue": 7820.185546875, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.47504425048828, "totalFees": 3328.884521484375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08841059356927872 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -21.798145294189453, "finalValue": 7820.185546875, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.47504425048828, "totalFees": 3328.884521484375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08841059356927872 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -21.798145294189453, "finalValue": 7820.185546875, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.47504425048828, "totalFees": 3328.884521484375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08841059356927872 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -21.798145294189453, "finalValue": 7820.185546875, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.47504425048828, "totalFees": 3328.884521484375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08841059356927872 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -21.344327926635742, "finalValue": 7865.5673828125, "totalTrades": 322, "winRate": 34.78260803222656, "maxDrawdownPct": 48.1760368347168, "totalFees": 3331.003662109375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.08892364799976349 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": 7.90636682510376, "finalValue": 10790.63671875, "totalTrades": 79, "winRate": 38.46154022216797, "maxDrawdownPct": 23.76060676574707, "totalFees": 823.3614501953125, "finalCoinAmount": 0.12199282646179199 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": 34.898162841796875, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 108.95822143554688, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1833, "same_return": 964, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 964, "lower_return": 998, "same_count_different_return": 869, "more_executions": 1117, "higher_return": 1163, "fewer_executions": 175 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3125, "same_return": 3125, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 3125 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 224, "lower_return": 2326, "same_count_different_return": 224, "higher_return": 2049, "fewer_executions": 4151 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B003-btcusdt-later-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "5a472fba010e0de163cd4cabc017ae95d48926ca4f8a4019acec768b36446545" }, { "batch": "B004", "symbol": "ETHUSDT", "window": "later", "start_date": "2024-01-01", "end_date": "2025-12-31", "candleSize": "2h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 2254, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": -19.303897857666016, "finalValue": 8069.6103515625, "totalTrades": 598, "winRate": 34.44816207885742, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.613441467285156, "totalFees": 6536.94189453125, "finalCoinAmount": 2.7078046798706055 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": -40.525550842285156, "finalValue": 5947.44482421875, "totalTrades": 654, "winRate": 36.39143753051758, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.15383529663086, "totalFees": 6095.990234375, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9956997632980347 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -41.72121047973633, "finalValue": 5827.87890625, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6127.73046875, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9555786848068237 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -41.24220657348633, "finalValue": 5875.779296875, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6158.7314453125, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9716519117355347 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -41.24220657348633, "finalValue": 5875.779296875, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6158.7314453125, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9716519117355347 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -41.24220657348633, "finalValue": 5875.779296875, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6158.7314453125, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9716519117355347 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -41.24220657348633, "finalValue": 5875.779296875, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6158.7314453125, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9716519117355347 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -41.72121047973633, "finalValue": 5827.87890625, "totalTrades": 666, "winRate": 36.93693542480469, "maxDrawdownPct": 57.51720428466797, "totalFees": 6127.73046875, "finalCoinAmount": 1.9555786848068237 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": 11.264220237731934, "finalValue": 11126.421875, "totalTrades": 163, "winRate": 37.03703689575195, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.32106018066406, "totalFees": 1817.7548828125, "finalCoinAmount": 3.7335357666015625 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": 18.371307373046875, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 29.36164093017578, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1225, "same_return": 1005, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 1005, "more_executions": 1855, "lower_return": 487, "same_count_different_return": 220, "fewer_executions": 45, "higher_return": 1633 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3106, "same_return": 2730, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 2730, "lower_return": 312, "same_count_different_return": 376, "more_executions": 19, "higher_return": 83 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 63, "lower_return": 2673, "same_count_different_return": 63, "fewer_executions": 4312, "higher_return": 1702 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B004-ethusdt-later-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "0c37e460e463ac4ae9c35d6a33143f3ece08dab40a83097447368761f2596c77" }, { "batch": "B004", "symbol": "ETHUSDT", "window": "later", "start_date": "2024-01-01", "end_date": "2025-12-31", "candleSize": "4h", "valid": 21875, "traded": 21875, "profitable": 9426, "cap_profile": [ { "cap": 0.1, "totalReturn": 15.843331336975098, "finalValue": 11584.3330078125, "totalTrades": 266, "winRate": 39.09774398803711, "maxDrawdownPct": 46.59048843383789, "totalFees": 3156.71923828125, "finalCoinAmount": 3.899542808532715 }, { "cap": 0.15, "totalReturn": 7.115222930908203, "finalValue": 10711.5224609375, "totalTrades": 296, "winRate": 41.216217041015625, "maxDrawdownPct": 47.86005783081055, "totalFees": 3591.443115234375, "finalCoinAmount": 3.6057355403900146 }, { "cap": 0.2, "totalReturn": -11.891804695129395, "finalValue": 8810.8193359375, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3345.1279296875, "finalCoinAmount": 2.965916872024536 }, { "cap": 0.25, "totalReturn": -11.891804695129395, "finalValue": 8810.8193359375, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3345.1279296875, "finalCoinAmount": 2.965916872024536 }, { "cap": 0.3, "totalReturn": -12.41576862335205, "finalValue": 8758.4228515625, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3331.747802734375, "finalCoinAmount": 2.9482791423797607 }, { "cap": 0.4, "totalReturn": -12.41576862335205, "finalValue": 8758.4228515625, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3331.747802734375, "finalCoinAmount": 2.9482791423797607 }, { "cap": 0.5, "totalReturn": -12.41576862335205, "finalValue": 8758.4228515625, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3331.747802734375, "finalCoinAmount": 2.9482791423797607 } ], "representatives": [ { "label": "Familiar default", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.02, "sar_step": 0.02, "sar_max": 0.2, "confirm_bars": 1 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -11.891804695129395, "finalValue": 8810.8193359375, "totalTrades": 304, "winRate": 38.157894134521484, "maxDrawdownPct": 55.336952209472656, "totalFees": 3345.1279296875, "finalCoinAmount": 2.965916872024536 } }, { "label": "Exploratory early four-hour winner", "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.006, "sar_step": 0.002, "sar_max": 0.1, "confirm_bars": 5 }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -17.68099594116211, "finalValue": 8231.900390625, "totalTrades": 75, "winRate": 29.7297306060791, "maxDrawdownPct": 36.68148422241211, "totalFees": 639.4646606445312, "finalCoinAmount": 2.7710399627685547 } } ], "matching_start_passive_return_pct": -12.264678001403809, "full_window_platform_buy_hold_pct": 30.64811897277832, "comparisons": { "cap_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.2, "b": 0.4, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 1350, "same_return": 805, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 805, "more_executions": 1759, "lower_return": 1517, "same_count_different_return": 545, "higher_return": 803, "fewer_executions": 16 } }, "cap_plateau_pairs": { "axis": "sar_max", "a": 0.4, "b": 0.5, "observed_a": 3125, "observed_b": 3125, "observed_both": 3125, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 3125, "same_return": 3125, "all_selected_metrics_identical": 3125 } }, "confirmation_pairs": { "axis": "confirm_bars", "a": 1, "b": 2, "observed_a": 4375, "observed_b": 4375, "observed_both": 4375, "observed_a_only": 0, "observed_b_only": 0, "counts": { "same_executions": 378, "lower_return": 2669, "same_count_different_return": 378, "fewer_executions": 3997, "higher_return": 1706 } } }, "raw_export_basename": "B004-ethusdt-later-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "0c37e460e463ac4ae9c35d6a33143f3ece08dab40a83097447368761f2596c77" } ], "matching_start_passive_note": "Reused earlier independently audited exact-frame single-purchase TrainBard controls with same capital, allocation, fee, startup and endpoints. These are not new SAR evaluations.", "fixed_default_confirmation_example": { "batch": "B001", "symbol": "BTCUSDT", "candleSize": "2h", "start_date": "2021-01-01", "end_date": "2023-12-31", "raw_export_basename": "B001-btcusdt-early-43750.json", "raw_export_sha256": "453d4ccafa8cbfdf0a76f4327a968b0eab95c5b9711f02f8235c2785d3d650a8", "note": "Exact main-grid rows underlying the prose example. The separate default smoke repeats their selected metrics exactly and is excluded from the headline count.", "rows": [ { "confirmation_bars": 1, "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.019999999552965164, "sar_step": 0.019999999552965164, "sar_max": 0.20000000298023224, "confirm_bars": 1, "candleSize": "2h" }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -80.02999114990234, "finalValue": 1997.001220703125, "totalTrades": 963, "winRate": 30.977130889892578, "maxDrawdownPct": 83.74506378173828, "totalFees": 3710.26708984375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04735526069998741 } }, { "confirmation_bars": 2, "parameters": { "sar_start": 0.019999999552965164, "sar_step": 0.019999999552965164, "sar_max": 0.20000000298023224, "confirm_bars": 2, "candleSize": "2h" }, "metrics": { "totalReturn": -81.47099304199219, "finalValue": 1852.901123046875, "totalTrades": 921, "winRate": 31.7391300201416, "maxDrawdownPct": 85.28865814208984, "totalFees": 3307.83740234375, "finalCoinAmount": 0.04393818974494934 } } ] } }